I'm excited to be speaking at this conference on genital cutting at the University of Leeds at the end of April.
My talk - 'Campaigning for (circumcision) change: some ideas for the UK' - draws on my experiences and insights campaigning for equal civil partnerships. In it, I will suggest what I consider to be the most attainable and measurable objective for change; consider the feasibility, and potential advantages, of running a Judicial Review case aimed at challenging the unequal legal treatment of girls’ and boys’ genitals; explore how such a case could complement a broader political campaign; consider the limitations of legal challenges and changes; identify the merits of differing campaign messages (equality and human rights versus child protection, for example); and suggest some avenues for fundraising.
If you'd like to hear more from me and from an incredible group of academics, lawyers, doctors and activists about why a commitment to child's rights means extending protections to the genitals of male and intersex children too, please do come along. Hope to see you there.
Here is a link to eventbrite to book tickets.
Showing posts with label Circumcision. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Circumcision. Show all posts
Thursday, 21 February 2019
'Campaigning for (circumcision) change: some ideas for the UK' - upcoming talk at the University of Leeds
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
feminism,
FGM,
gender,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights
Thursday, 25 May 2017
How different are female, male and intersex genital cutting? Brian Earp's and my article in last week's The Conversation
Last week, my bioethicist colleague Brian Earp and I published an article in The Conversation asking how different are female, male and intersex genital cutting.
We frame our article around the recent indictment of three members of the Dawoodi Bohra sect of Islam on charges of “female genital mutilation” (FGM) in the US state of Michigan, and the decision by one of Norway's major political parties to back a measure to ban childhood male circumcision.
In Western countries, popular attitudes towards these procedures differ sharply depending on the child’s sex. But in our article we ask whether the supposedly clear distinction between these different forms of genital cutting stand up to scrutiny.
Having concluded that they do not, we argue that moral considerations should instead centre around medical necessity, autonomy, and respect for the bodily integrity of all children – regardless of their sex or gender.
We outline three practical advantages to this approach:
1) It deflects accusations of sexism by recognising that boys and intersex children – just like girls – are vulnerable to genital alterations that they may later come to seriously resent.
2) It reduces the moral confusion that stems from Western-led efforts to eliminate only the female “half” of genital cutting rites in communities that practice both male and female forms in parallel.
3) It neutralises accusations of cultural imperialism and anti-Muslim bias by avoiding racially tinged double standards.
This is because the same moral concern would apply to medically unnecessary genital cutting practices that primarily affect white children in North America, Australasia and Europe, as to those affecting children of colour (and immigrants) from Africa, the Middle East and Southeast Asia.
As we explain in our article, adopting such an approach does not necessarily mean “banning” all pre-consensual forms of non-therapeutic genital alteration. History shows that attempting to pass strict legal prohibitions before cultural readiness can backfire, creating intense resistance among those who are dedicated to modifying children’s genitals for whatever reason, and often driving such practices further underground.
Rather, there are many levers that societies can pull to discourage unethical practices: the law is only one among them, and not necessarily the most desirable or effective. Some authors have proposed step-wise regulation of medically unnecessary childhood genital cutting, along with community engagement and education, as alternatives and/or supplements to formal prohibition.
As Brian and I conclude, whatever specific policies are implemented, it is clear that fundamentally different treatment of female, male and intersex children, in terms of their protection from non-therapeutic genital alteration, will become increasingly difficult to justify in the years to come.
To read our article in full, please click here. We welcome your comments.
We frame our article around the recent indictment of three members of the Dawoodi Bohra sect of Islam on charges of “female genital mutilation” (FGM) in the US state of Michigan, and the decision by one of Norway's major political parties to back a measure to ban childhood male circumcision.
In Western countries, popular attitudes towards these procedures differ sharply depending on the child’s sex. But in our article we ask whether the supposedly clear distinction between these different forms of genital cutting stand up to scrutiny.
Having concluded that they do not, we argue that moral considerations should instead centre around medical necessity, autonomy, and respect for the bodily integrity of all children – regardless of their sex or gender.
We outline three practical advantages to this approach:
1) It deflects accusations of sexism by recognising that boys and intersex children – just like girls – are vulnerable to genital alterations that they may later come to seriously resent.
2) It reduces the moral confusion that stems from Western-led efforts to eliminate only the female “half” of genital cutting rites in communities that practice both male and female forms in parallel.
3) It neutralises accusations of cultural imperialism and anti-Muslim bias by avoiding racially tinged double standards.
This is because the same moral concern would apply to medically unnecessary genital cutting practices that primarily affect white children in North America, Australasia and Europe, as to those affecting children of colour (and immigrants) from Africa, the Middle East and Southeast Asia.
As we explain in our article, adopting such an approach does not necessarily mean “banning” all pre-consensual forms of non-therapeutic genital alteration. History shows that attempting to pass strict legal prohibitions before cultural readiness can backfire, creating intense resistance among those who are dedicated to modifying children’s genitals for whatever reason, and often driving such practices further underground.
Rather, there are many levers that societies can pull to discourage unethical practices: the law is only one among them, and not necessarily the most desirable or effective. Some authors have proposed step-wise regulation of medically unnecessary childhood genital cutting, along with community engagement and education, as alternatives and/or supplements to formal prohibition.
As Brian and I conclude, whatever specific policies are implemented, it is clear that fundamentally different treatment of female, male and intersex children, in terms of their protection from non-therapeutic genital alteration, will become increasingly difficult to justify in the years to come.
To read our article in full, please click here. We welcome your comments.
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
feminism,
FGM,
gender,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
law,
Politics
Monday, 24 April 2017
“Gender and Genital Cutting: A New Paradigm” – bioethicist Brian Earp’s and my recent paper for the European Parliament
My bioethicist
colleague, Brian Earp, and I have recently published a paper for the European
Parliament on the
non-therapeutic cutting of children’s genitals.
In it, we explain
that though moral
and legal opposition to the non-therapeutic cutting of children’s genitals has
traditionally focused on female children, a growing movement of scholars,
activists, and individuals affected by childhood genital cutting have argued
that all children, regardless of sex or gender, should be protected from such
intimate violations.
In our paper, we argue, first, that
the conventional distinctions based on sex or gender do not reliably reflect
the actual harms that are entailed by various forms of NGC; and secondly that
distinctions based on autonomy and informed consent do provide coherent grounds
for an empirically justifiable analysis of the moral permissibility of NGC.
These conclusions have significant implications for policy. At a recent
WHO-sponsored conference on female NGC held at Geneva University Hospitals, we
argued that a gender-inclusive approach, based on an individual’s capacity to
provide informed consent to NGC, is not only better supported by the available
evidence, but also offers several practical advantages:
- It deflects accusations of sexism by recognizing that boys and intersex children are also vulnerable to non-therapeutic genital alterations that they may later come to seriously resent.
- It clarifies the moral confusion that stems from Western-led efforts to eliminate only the female “half” of childhood NGC practices in communities that practice both male and female NGC in parallel.
- It neutralizes accusations of cultural imperialism by applying the same standards to medically unnecessary genital cutting practices primarily affecting white minors in North America, Australasia, and Europe (i.e., medicalized routine or religious male circumcision, and intersex genital normalization surgery) as it does to such practices primarily affecting minors of color in Africa, the Middle East, and Southeast Asia (i.e., male and female peripubertal initiation ceremonies and other customary forms of childhood NGC).
Adopting such an
approach does not necessarily mean seeking to prohibit all pre-consensual forms
of NGC. Experience shows that the enactment of strict legal prohibitions prior
to cultural readiness can backfire, creating intense resistance among those who
are dedicated to the practice, and often driving it further underground.
Prohibition of childhood female NGC, for example, has been largely unsuccessful
in many countries where it is customary and deeply embedded, and recent attempts
to criminalise circumcision of boys have been blocked, ignored or overturned.
There are,
however, many “levers” society that can pull to discourage harmful practices:
the law is only one among many, and not necessarily the most desirable or
effective. Some authors have proposed step-wise regulation of childhood NGCs,
along with community engagement and education, as alternatives and/or
supplements to formal prohibition.
Whatever specific
policies are implemented, it is clear that fundamentally different treatment of
female, male, and intersex children, in terms of their protection from nontherapeutic
genital cutting, will become increasingly difficult to justify, morally, legally
or medically, in years to come.
To read
our full analysis, please
go to Euromind:
http://euromind.global/brian-d-earp-and-rebecca-steinfeld/?lang=en
---
Our thanks go to Eduardo Zugasti, assisting MEP Teresa Giménez Barbat, for inviting us to prepare this essay, and to Professor Elizabeth Reis and Dr. Robert Darby for feedback on an earlier draft.
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
FGM,
gender,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
law
Wednesday, 15 March 2017
FGM/C Geneva conference presentation: Could efforts to eliminate female genital cutting be strengthened by extending protections to male and intersex children?
Over the last two days, I participated in an inspiring and enriching conference on Female Genital Mutilation/Cutting at the Geneva University Hospitals. There, I met so many incredible people working so hard on such complex issues.
I also shared some of my bioethicist colleague Brian Earp's and my research on whether efforts to eliminate female genital cutting could be strengthened by extending protections to male and intersex children. We created and displayed this eposter to summarise our analysis and arguments:
In my presentation, I recognised that comparing female genital cutting with male and intersex genital alteration is controversial. At the same time, I emphasised that there are significant areas of overlap between these practices that necessitate reconsideration of their divergent ethical statuses and policy treatments.
Finally, we made two arguments for extending protections to male and intersex children. The first was an ethical argument, namely that consent, not sex, should form the basis of policy: All children should be protected from non-consensual, non-therapeutic cutting of their genitalia.
The second was an effectiveness argument: That efforts to eliminate FGC will only be successful if they expand to include vulnerable persons of all genders.
Participants' reactions to our analysis were very encouraging. Everyone was enthusiastically and vocally supportive of the need to apply principles of bodily integrity consistently to children of all genders.
Thank you to the organisers for providing the space for this important conversation. Here's to many more discussions like this!
I also shared some of my bioethicist colleague Brian Earp's and my research on whether efforts to eliminate female genital cutting could be strengthened by extending protections to male and intersex children. We created and displayed this eposter to summarise our analysis and arguments:
In my presentation, I recognised that comparing female genital cutting with male and intersex genital alteration is controversial. At the same time, I emphasised that there are significant areas of overlap between these practices that necessitate reconsideration of their divergent ethical statuses and policy treatments.
I explained that some argue that efforts to reduce FGC are undermined by failing to apply principles of bodily
integrity to children of all sexes. While a sex-based approach is incompatible
with equality principles, it could also backfire because some defenders of male
circumcision call for 'nicking' of females' genitalia for intellectual consistency. Essentially they're seeking to 'equalise down' by rolling back existing protections for females.
By contrast, Brian and I have identified three advantages of a gender-inclusive approach:
- It negates accusations of cultural imperialism by applying the same standards to white children in the USA as to children of colour in Africa.
- It weakens accusations of sexism by recognising that boys and intersex children are also vulnerable to non-therapeutic genital alteration.
- It clarifies the moral confusion caused by applying a gendered-double standard to communities that modify both sexes' genitals.
Finally, we made two arguments for extending protections to male and intersex children. The first was an ethical argument, namely that consent, not sex, should form the basis of policy: All children should be protected from non-consensual, non-therapeutic cutting of their genitalia.
The second was an effectiveness argument: That efforts to eliminate FGC will only be successful if they expand to include vulnerable persons of all genders.
Participants' reactions to our analysis were very encouraging. Everyone was enthusiastically and vocally supportive of the need to apply principles of bodily integrity consistently to children of all genders.
Thank you to the organisers for providing the space for this important conversation. Here's to many more discussions like this!
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
feminism,
FGM,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
law
Friday, 3 March 2017
Workshops on Brit Milah and Brit Shalom at the JCC in Zurich on Sunday 19th March
I'm thrilled to have been invited to present at an emancipation-themed Jewish day of learning at the JCC in Zurich on Sunday 19th March. I'll be presenting two sessions, one on Brit Milah and the other on Brit Shalom.
Here are my session descriptions:
Here are my session descriptions:
ANALYZING THE DEBATES AROUND BRIT MILAH
(13:45 – 15:00)
Brit Milah is a profoundly meaningful Jewish practice imbued with great religious and cultural value. For many Jews, it is an ancient covenant that affirms their son’s Jewish identity and belonging. At the same time, some Jews are questioning the practice, reflecting broader discussions taking place across Europe and beyond. In this session, we will explore these debates, and learn more about the ethical and scientific research on circumcision. The session is open to all: those who would/did circumcise their son, those who have reservations, and those who have never before considered the question.
CELEBRATIONS TO WELCOME NEWBORN BABIES
(15:30 – 16:45)
Many parents welcome their newborn child into the Jewish community with a formal ceremony. While most perform Brit Milah for boys (in a variety of settings), others are turning to non-surgical and/or gender-inclusive ceremonies like Brit Shalom. In this practical session, we will learn about different types of baby-welcoming ceremonies being used in Jewish communities. We will discuss different possible structures for such ceremonies, how to incorporate Jewish and other content, and learn about some related prayers, psalms and songs. Participants are invited to share their experiences, ideas and insights.
Labels:
Circumcision,
ethics,
feminism,
gender,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
law
Tuesday, 15 November 2016
Upcoming talk at UCL - 'Genital alteration and gender equality: the future of policy' - Wednesday 23rd November
At UCL next week, I will present my research on gender and genital alteration. My talk is entitled 'Genital alteration and gender equality: the future of policy.' It is part of the Institute of Advanced Studies' Gender and Feminism Network's seminar series.
In the talk, I will critique contrasting global policies toward female and male genital alteration. These policies focus on eliminating female genital mutilation, or FGM, while tolerating or even encouraging male circumcision.
I will explain that, on the surface, this seems unproblematic: Within global health and human rights circles, FGM is almost universally regarded as a barbaric manifestation of the patriarchal drive to control female sexuality, whereas male circumcision is seen as benign.
Yet, I will point to the mounting empirical evidence and ethical critique that calls into question these contrasting perceptions and policies.
I will argue that maintaining policies premised on sex-based distinctions seems unsustainable and incompatible with gender equality. Instead, I will suggest that meaningful age-based distinctions between those unable (children) and able (adults) to give informed consent could constitute better policy.
I will evaluate the merits of permissive and restrictive approaches to female and male genital alteration, assessing the advantages of specific policies. In so doing, I will argue for gender equality in genital alteration policies.
My talk stems from a wonderful collaborative partnership with my brilliant bioethicist friend and colleague, Brian Earp. We spent last summer conducting research at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva on a project entitled 'The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy.'
---
Event details:
Date: Wednesday 23rd November
Time: 4:30-6:00 PM
In the talk, I will critique contrasting global policies toward female and male genital alteration. These policies focus on eliminating female genital mutilation, or FGM, while tolerating or even encouraging male circumcision.
I will explain that, on the surface, this seems unproblematic: Within global health and human rights circles, FGM is almost universally regarded as a barbaric manifestation of the patriarchal drive to control female sexuality, whereas male circumcision is seen as benign.
Yet, I will point to the mounting empirical evidence and ethical critique that calls into question these contrasting perceptions and policies.
I will argue that maintaining policies premised on sex-based distinctions seems unsustainable and incompatible with gender equality. Instead, I will suggest that meaningful age-based distinctions between those unable (children) and able (adults) to give informed consent could constitute better policy.
I will evaluate the merits of permissive and restrictive approaches to female and male genital alteration, assessing the advantages of specific policies. In so doing, I will argue for gender equality in genital alteration policies.
My talk stems from a wonderful collaborative partnership with my brilliant bioethicist friend and colleague, Brian Earp. We spent last summer conducting research at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva on a project entitled 'The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy.'
---
Event details:
Date: Wednesday 23rd November
Time: 4:30-6:00 PM
Location: IAS Seminar Room 19, First Floor, South Wing, Wilkins Building
For more information, see the Institute of Advanced Studies' event page here.
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
feminism,
FGM,
gender,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
law
Monday, 22 August 2016
My talk on 'Genital Alteration: Towards More Empirical, Ethical and Effective Policies' at Keele University, 14 September
I am looking forward to sharing my research on policies towards female and male genital alteration at the 14th International Symposium on Genital Autonomy at Keele University on 14 September 2016.
As I explain in my abstract, global and Western states’ policies toward genital alteration tend to focus on eliminating female genital mutilation, or FGM, while tolerating or even encouraging male circumcision. On the surface, this seems unproblematic: Within global health and human rights circles, FGM is almost universally regarded as bad and barbaric – as a savage and severely harmful manifestation of the patriarchal drive to control female sexuality – whereas male circumcision is seen as benign or even beneficial. Yet mounting empirical evidence and ethical critique calls into question these contrasting perceptions, and, in turn, the divergent policies they underpin. In this paper, I argue that maintaining policies premised on sex-based distinctions seems unsustainable, as well as incompatible with gender equality. Instead, I suggest that meaningful age-based distinctions between those unable (children) and able (adults) to give informed consent could constitute more empirical, ethical and effective policies. I evaluate the merits and demerits of both permissive and restrictive approaches to female and male genital alteration, and assess the advantages and disadvantages of some specific alternative policies.
My talk stems from a wonderful collaborative partnership with my brilliant bioethicist friend and colleague, Brian Earp. Together, we have spent the summer conducting research at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva on a project entitled "The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy."
For more information about my talk, see here.
For more information about the symposium and its programme, see here.
For more information about Brian Earp's and my research together, see here.
As I explain in my abstract, global and Western states’ policies toward genital alteration tend to focus on eliminating female genital mutilation, or FGM, while tolerating or even encouraging male circumcision. On the surface, this seems unproblematic: Within global health and human rights circles, FGM is almost universally regarded as bad and barbaric – as a savage and severely harmful manifestation of the patriarchal drive to control female sexuality – whereas male circumcision is seen as benign or even beneficial. Yet mounting empirical evidence and ethical critique calls into question these contrasting perceptions, and, in turn, the divergent policies they underpin. In this paper, I argue that maintaining policies premised on sex-based distinctions seems unsustainable, as well as incompatible with gender equality. Instead, I suggest that meaningful age-based distinctions between those unable (children) and able (adults) to give informed consent could constitute more empirical, ethical and effective policies. I evaluate the merits and demerits of both permissive and restrictive approaches to female and male genital alteration, and assess the advantages and disadvantages of some specific alternative policies.
My talk stems from a wonderful collaborative partnership with my brilliant bioethicist friend and colleague, Brian Earp. Together, we have spent the summer conducting research at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva on a project entitled "The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy."
For more information about my talk, see here.
For more information about the symposium and its programme, see here.
For more information about Brian Earp's and my research together, see here.
Labels:
Circumcision,
equality,
ethics,
feminism,
FGM,
genital alteration,
genital cutting,
human rights,
Politics
Wednesday, 29 June 2016
Upcoming research with brilliant bioethicist Brian Earp at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva
I am extremely excited to soon be joining my brilliant bioethicist friend and colleague, Brian Earp, at the Brocher Foundation in Geneva for a month long residency of researching and writing about male circumcision.
Our project, entitled "The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy," will involve our planning and organising an academic conference on male circumcision featuring the leading researchers on this subject from ethics, history, law, medicine, religious studies, and across the social and political sciences. We hope that the output of this conference will form the basis of an edited collection of essays on a range of circumcision-related topics and debates.
For more information on the research we have planned during our joint residency, please see my researcher profile here.
Our project, entitled "The Science, Politics, and Ethics of Male Circumcision: An Interdisciplinary Take on an Emerging Global Controversy," will involve our planning and organising an academic conference on male circumcision featuring the leading researchers on this subject from ethics, history, law, medicine, religious studies, and across the social and political sciences. We hope that the output of this conference will form the basis of an edited collection of essays on a range of circumcision-related topics and debates.
For more information on the research we have planned during our joint residency, please see my researcher profile here.
Tuesday, 26 November 2013
It cuts both ways: A Jew argues for child rights over religious circumcision
I've just published my debut blog as a Jewish Thinker for Israel's Haaretz newspaper on the topic of circumcision. Below are the first 150 words, and in 48 hours I'll re-post the whole article.
-----------------------
Two years ago, in response to an article I wrote questioning circumcision, the British historian Geoffrey Alderman dedicated his column to my character assassination, describing me as “a leading anti-Jewish Jew of the younger generation.” Though I appreciated the attention, I was disappointed – why not “the” leading anti-Jewish Jew? It would have brought my parents such nachas.
Still, I was luckier than the Council of Europe: After it passed a motion declaring the circumcision of young boys for religious reasons “a violation of the physical integrity of children,” Israel’s Foreign Ministry accused it of fostering “hate and racist trends in Europe.” With accusations flying, the Council’s special rapporteur, Marlene Rupprecht, countered that the “vote does not intend to stigmatize any religious community or its practices,” but to reach “a wide consensus on the rights of children.”
So, who’s right?
This article was originally published by Haaretz. For the full article, click here.
-----------------------
Two years ago, in response to an article I wrote questioning circumcision, the British historian Geoffrey Alderman dedicated his column to my character assassination, describing me as “a leading anti-Jewish Jew of the younger generation.” Though I appreciated the attention, I was disappointed – why not “the” leading anti-Jewish Jew? It would have brought my parents such nachas.
Still, I was luckier than the Council of Europe: After it passed a motion declaring the circumcision of young boys for religious reasons “a violation of the physical integrity of children,” Israel’s Foreign Ministry accused it of fostering “hate and racist trends in Europe.” With accusations flying, the Council’s special rapporteur, Marlene Rupprecht, countered that the “vote does not intend to stigmatize any religious community or its practices,” but to reach “a wide consensus on the rights of children.”
So, who’s right?
This article was originally published by Haaretz. For the full article, click here.
Labels:
anti-Semitism,
Circumcision,
Holocaust,
human rights,
Israel,
Judaism
Tuesday, 19 November 2013
For International Men's Day: "Like FGM, cut foreskins should be a feminist issue"
To mark International Men's Day today, here is a piece I published yesterday entitled, "Like FGM, cut foreskins should be a feminist issue":
https://theconversation.com/like-fgm-cut-foreskins-should-be-a-feminist-issue-20328
In the piece, I explain that though comparing male and female genital cutting is usually dismissed or condemned, my research suggests the situation is more complex. Leading medical ethicists, historians, and legal scholars think that FGC and MGC overlap in ways that question the distinct labels and laws applied to them. For example, along with the serious harm that both FGC and MGC can cause, both occur without the consent of the child, and irreversibly violate the child’s human right to physical integrity. In so doing, FGC and MGC both prioritise the cultural or religious beliefs of parents over their child’s right to self-determination and an open future.
Despite these overlaps, the two been treated differently, partly because of the difference in harm, but also because of misperceptions about the contrasting settings and ages at which the procedures take place, and due to sexism and ethnocentrism. Specifically, male bodies are constructed as resistant to harm or even in need of being tested by painful ordeals, whereas female bodies are seen as highly vulnerable and in need of protection. In other words, vulnerability is gendered. And little girls are more readily seen as victims than little boys.
I conclude that it’s time to re-examine our gender and cultural assumptions about genital cutting, and take a non-discriminatory, intellectually consistent approach.
I am grateful to The Conversation for publishing this article. The Conversation "is an independent source of news and views, sourced from the academic and research community and delivered direct to the public." For more information, click here: https://theconversation.com/uk/who_we_are
I hope you find my article thought provoking.
Tuesday, 22 October 2013
Cutting Tradition at the Sage in Gateshead for BBC Radio 3's Free Thinking Festival of Ideas
What is the place of religious traditions involving genital cutting in today’s world? How do we draw the line between parents’ rights and religious liberty on the one hand, and children’s rights on the other? These are very difficult questions...
I am going to attempt to answer them in only 13.5 minutes this Sunday (October 27) at the Sage in Gateshead as part of BBC Radio 3's Free Thinking Festival of Ideas.
I am going to look at recent debates among medical ethicists and lawyers about male infant circumcision, performed on around one third of the world’s male population. I will explore what these debates reveal about the relationships between parents and children, religion and human rights, and the differences between male and female bodies.
I am going to look at recent debates among medical ethicists and lawyers about male infant circumcision, performed on around one third of the world’s male population. I will explore what these debates reveal about the relationships between parents and children, religion and human rights, and the differences between male and female bodies.
Labels:
Circumcision,
feminism,
gender,
human rights,
Islam,
Judaism,
law
Monday, 4 July 2011
"We Should Be Free To Debate"
I published this piece in The Jewish Chronicle in July 2011 after my position as an Under-35 Observer to the Board of Deputies of British Jews was rescinded in light of the article I co-authored in The Guardian on circumcision, together with the press in The JC itself. In this article, I call on the Jewish community to continue following the tradition of constantly questioning and seeking truth to find answers to difficult questions.
http://www.thejc.com/comment-and-debate/comment/51143/we-should-be-free-debate
http://www.thejc.com/comment-and-debate/comment/51143/we-should-be-free-debate
Tuesday, 14 June 2011
On Circumcision
In this piece, published in The Guardian in June 2011, my friend and colleague, Neil Howard, and I discuss male infant circumcision. We ask whether the differences between male and female circumcision are so straightforward as to justify a distinction in the law. The article was prompted by a bill in San Francisco in 2011 that proposed to outlaw the circumcising, cutting, or mutilation of the foreskin, testicles, or penis of another person aged under 18, with an exemption for cases of medical necessity, but not for custom or ritual. Unsurprisingly, the bill attracted considerable controversy at the time, primarily from feminists who objected to the idea of comparing male and female genital cutting, as well as from those who regard attempts to limit the practice of infant male circumcision as a modern manifestation of anti-Semitism. We explored some of these issues.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2011/jun/14/circumcision-ban-row-san-francisco
http://www.guardian.co.uk/law/2011/jun/14/circumcision-ban-row-san-francisco
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

